There’s an absolute ton of amazing pizza to be had in Wisconsin. Heck, we’ve even made an extensive list about it. We’ve got Wisconsin-style pizza, square-cut pizza and even pizza served fresh on the farm. But one place in southeastern Wisconsin has some of the best pizza you’ve probably never heard of. In business for nearly a century and in their third generation of family ownership, Wells Brothers Pizza in Wisconsin is a total hidden gem. The restaurant is unassuming and the presentation is simple, but all that does is allow their stellar pizza to shine. Head over to Racine to try it for yourself.
Established way back in 1921, Wells Brothers was founded by Dominic and James Wells. Their pizza has been made the same way, in this same building, ever since.
Yelp/Charles B
The pizza here has been winning awards longer than most of us have been alive. As recently as 2005, they were named the #6 pizza in the nation.
Yelp/Charles B
feels like visiting family, especially if you’ve ever spent time with an Italian grandmother. It’s friendly, welcoming and cozy in the best way.
Wells Brothers Pizza/Facebook
Though the pizza is the star here, there’s a constantly changing and updating specials board.
Facebook/WellsBrosPizza
The crust is that amazing cracker-thin style that we love here in the Dairy State.
Facebook/WellsBrosPizza The pizza isn’t overly greasy, and the sausage has that perfect hint of fennel.
The sauce here has just the right amount of sweetness and they don’t skimp on the toppings - there’s plenty of melty, bubbly mozzarella to act as a base for your pie, but not so much that it ruins the cracker crust. No soggy bottoms here!
Yelp/Charles B Regulars highly suggest ordering the pizza well done - those extra few minutes in the oven give you crispy, crunchy edges and that perfect snap of the crust that leaves you with crumbs on your shirt.
Wells Brothers is well worth the short drive from Milwaukee to not only get truly stellar pizza, but to support a family-owned business that has been serving simple, flavorful and excellent food in the same spot for nearly 100 years.
Yelp/Joshua F One of the very best, very Wisconsin features of Wells Brothers is the cans of Hamm’s for less than a dollar (94 cents, to be exact). Pizza prices are super reasonable and on Tuesday nights, you can get a large pizza, garlic bread or fries and your choice of six beer shorties, a bottle of wine or a pitcher of soda for $20.
Wells Brothers Pizza is located at 2148 Mead St, Racine, 53403. To learn more, visit their website or Facebook page.
Yelp/Charles B
Wells Brothers Pizza/Facebook
Facebook/WellsBrosPizza
The pizza isn’t overly greasy, and the sausage has that perfect hint of fennel.
Regulars highly suggest ordering the pizza well done - those extra few minutes in the oven give you crispy, crunchy edges and that perfect snap of the crust that leaves you with crumbs on your shirt.
Yelp/Joshua F
One of the very best, very Wisconsin features of Wells Brothers is the cans of Hamm’s for less than a dollar (94 cents, to be exact). Pizza prices are super reasonable and on Tuesday nights, you can get a large pizza, garlic bread or fries and your choice of six beer shorties, a bottle of wine or a pitcher of soda for $20.
Have you eaten at Wells Brothers Pizza in Wisconsin? Where else do you love to go in Wisconsin for great pizza in the least expected spots? Let us know in the comments. And if you know another scrumptious eatery we should feature, nominate it in our online form here.
If you’re hungry for more mouthwatering eats, visit these 11 restaurants in Wisconsin that serve grilled cheese sandwiches to die for.
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
Address: 2148 Mead St, Mt Pleasant, WI 53403, USA
The OIYS Visitor Center
Wells Brothers Pizza in Wisconsin May 17, 2020 Elisa Regulski What are the best hole-in-the-wall restaurants in Wisconsin? There are so many exceptional hole-in-the-wall restaurants worth discovering in Wisconsin. Al’s Hamburger Shop, located in Green Bay, serves some of the most mouthwatering hamburgers you’ve ever eaten. Full of rich and juicy flavor, these eats will put a smile on anyone’s face. Sure, the inside is small and simple, but the food is anything but ordinary. For more tasty eats, visit Chester’s Drive-In in Plymouth. This nostalgic eatery will give you a taste of days gone by. Be sure to save room for one of their incredible ice cream sundaes. What are the best pizza places in Wisconsin? Looking for the best pizza in Wisconsin? You’ve got to take a trip to Angelo’s Pizza Villa in Wausau. This mom and pop joint makes pies with thin and crispy crusts, and there’s a variety of toppings to choose from. Luigi’s Pizza Kitchen and Restaurant, located in Kenosha, is another must-visit pizza place in Wisconsin. You’ll adore their cracker-thin crust and hospitable service. If you still need more foodie inspiration, check out our list of the 19 best pizza restaurants in Wisconsin. What are the best Italian restaurants in Wisconsin? If you’re craving authentic Italian dishes, head to Carmella’s in Appleton. This charming bistro makes some of the most scrumptious lasagna you’ve ever eaten. It’s almost too good to share! You’ll also find wonderful meals at Novanta in Madison. Their classic Neapolitan pizzas taste like they came straight from Italy. If it’s meatballs you’re after, visit Calderone Club in Milwaukee. These tasty eats are good enough to be the main meal, but you’ll definitely want to pair some of their amazing pasta with it. Dunk into a pool of marinara, and you’ll be in Italian food heaven.
The OIYS Visitor Center
Wells Brothers Pizza in Wisconsin
May 17, 2020
Elisa Regulski
What are the best hole-in-the-wall restaurants in Wisconsin? There are so many exceptional hole-in-the-wall restaurants worth discovering in Wisconsin. Al’s Hamburger Shop, located in Green Bay, serves some of the most mouthwatering hamburgers you’ve ever eaten. Full of rich and juicy flavor, these eats will put a smile on anyone’s face. Sure, the inside is small and simple, but the food is anything but ordinary. For more tasty eats, visit Chester’s Drive-In in Plymouth. This nostalgic eatery will give you a taste of days gone by. Be sure to save room for one of their incredible ice cream sundaes. What are the best pizza places in Wisconsin? Looking for the best pizza in Wisconsin? You’ve got to take a trip to Angelo’s Pizza Villa in Wausau. This mom and pop joint makes pies with thin and crispy crusts, and there’s a variety of toppings to choose from. Luigi’s Pizza Kitchen and Restaurant, located in Kenosha, is another must-visit pizza place in Wisconsin. You’ll adore their cracker-thin crust and hospitable service. If you still need more foodie inspiration, check out our list of the 19 best pizza restaurants in Wisconsin. What are the best Italian restaurants in Wisconsin? If you’re craving authentic Italian dishes, head to Carmella’s in Appleton. This charming bistro makes some of the most scrumptious lasagna you’ve ever eaten. It’s almost too good to share! You’ll also find wonderful meals at Novanta in Madison. Their classic Neapolitan pizzas taste like they came straight from Italy. If it’s meatballs you’re after, visit Calderone Club in Milwaukee. These tasty eats are good enough to be the main meal, but you’ll definitely want to pair some of their amazing pasta with it. Dunk into a pool of marinara, and you’ll be in Italian food heaven.
The OIYS Visitor Center
The OIYS Visitor Center
There are so many exceptional hole-in-the-wall restaurants worth discovering in Wisconsin. Al’s Hamburger Shop, located in Green Bay, serves some of the most mouthwatering hamburgers you’ve ever eaten. Full of rich and juicy flavor, these eats will put a smile on anyone’s face. Sure, the inside is small and simple, but the food is anything but ordinary. For more tasty eats, visit Chester’s Drive-In in Plymouth. This nostalgic eatery will give you a taste of days gone by. Be sure to save room for one of their incredible ice cream sundaes.
What are the best pizza places in Wisconsin?
Looking for the best pizza in Wisconsin? You’ve got to take a trip to Angelo’s Pizza Villa in Wausau. This mom and pop joint makes pies with thin and crispy crusts, and there’s a variety of toppings to choose from. Luigi’s Pizza Kitchen and Restaurant, located in Kenosha, is another must-visit pizza place in Wisconsin. You’ll adore their cracker-thin crust and hospitable service. If you still need more foodie inspiration, check out our list of the 19 best pizza restaurants in Wisconsin.
What are the best Italian restaurants in Wisconsin?
If you’re craving authentic Italian dishes, head to Carmella’s in Appleton. This charming bistro makes some of the most scrumptious lasagna you’ve ever eaten. It’s almost too good to share! You’ll also find wonderful meals at Novanta in Madison. Their classic Neapolitan pizzas taste like they came straight from Italy. If it’s meatballs you’re after, visit Calderone Club in Milwaukee. These tasty eats are good enough to be the main meal, but you’ll definitely want to pair some of their amazing pasta with it. Dunk into a pool of marinara, and you’ll be in Italian food heaven.
