Who doesn’t love a peanut butter and jelly sandwich? This childhood treat is classic for a reason. These nutty, fruity meals are packed full of nostalgia and remind us of our childhood. They’re full of protein and vitamins and are simple, but delicious. There’s a reason they’re iconic and the concept is basically a tenet of growing up. They’ve endured and become a basic part of childhood because they’re easy, so tasty and pack a bunch of the things parents want their kids to be eating. They don’t taste like they’re good for you and there’s a million ways to dress them up and make them unique. And it just so happens that there is a fantastic peanut butter and jelly shop in Wisconsin.
In the Six Points neighborhood of West Allis, outside Milwaukee, there’s a little deli that has perfected the PB&J. It’s an adorable little spot that bills itself as the world’s largest peanut butter and jelly shop. With more than 100 varieties of jam and jelly and a ton of nut butters that are made fresh in house daily, it’s easy to believe that these folks are doing peanut butter and jelly better than anyone else.
This peanut butter and jelly shop in Wisconsin must be seen to be believed. Check it out:
This adorable little spot is a fabulous choice for kids and adults alike. There’s a simple menu of options, but each sandwich can be customized in any number of ways, from choosing peanut or almond butter to a number of fresh-baked locally-produced breads.
Facebook/ThePBJDeli
Finish your sandwich off by choosing the perfect jam or jelly. There are more than 100 varieties to choose from here.
TripAdvisor/NikkiRoseG
But what really makes Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli stand out is that while you can definitely get the old standard, they’ve also got a menu full of jazzed up, unique and downright delicious PB&J options.
Facebook/ThePBJDeli
These folks never stop thinking outside the PB&J box. They’ve done peanut butter and jelly quesadillas, PB&J donuts, Oreos in a PB&J. Melty marshmallows. A PB&J made with pepper jelly, pepperjack cheese and jalapenos.
TripAdvisor/NikkiRoseG
Frankly, the options here are endless. These folks are constantly creating and testing and coming up with all kinds of options. This PB&J pancake stack is just one sample of how Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli are rethinking everything you knew about this classic sandwich.
Facebook/ThePBJDeli
The results are a deliciously huge array of mouthwatering, unique and oh-so-delicious sandwiches that your whole family will love. Even the pickiest of eaters will love a PB&J and parents won’t get stuck with another boring meal to appease the little ones. These sandwiches are kid tested and absolutely approved.
Facebook/ThePBJDeli
But while junior might just want a simple peanut butter, grape jelly and white bread sandwich, parents can kick it up with some of the most unique sandwiches they’ve ever imagined. Never has feeding the family been so easy or so delicious.
Facebook/ThePBJDeli
Of course, you can take their jellies home to try and replicate the whole experience again and again. Everything here is either made in house or made locally. They support local bakeries and farms to bring customers the very best fresh flavors.
Facebook/ThePBJDeli
You simply won’t regret a trip to Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli. They make the most unique, delicious and fabulous sandwiches that can even be delivered to local businesses or ordered online for a quick pick up.
Facebook/ThePBJDeli
You never knew your simple childhood favorite could be this amazing. One bite is both a flashback to a simpler time and an explosion of flavor that reminds you that as an adult, you can go back here as many times as you want to work your way through the whole darn menu.
Facebook/ThePBJDeli
Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli is located at 6125 W. Greenfield Ave., West Allis, WI 53214.
Facebook/ThePBJDeli
TripAdvisor/NikkiRoseG
Find out more about this awesome sandwich spot on their website or by checking out their Facebook page.
Speaking of jellies and jams, did you know there’s a country market in Door County that’s been selling some of the freshest jams in the country for more than 60 years?
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
Address: Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli, 6125 W Greenfield Ave, West Allis, WI 53214, USA
The OIYS Visitor Center
peanut butter and jelly shop in Wisconsin April 04, 2020 Elisa Regulski What are the most unique restaurants in Wisconsin? Georgie Porgie’s, located in Oak Creek and Mount Pleasant, is one of the most unique restaurants in Wisconsin. As soon as you step inside, you’ll feel like you entered another world. Yes, this eatery is treehouse-themed, and it’s just as magical as it sounds. Enjoy delicious burgers and freshly made custard. You’re going to love this one-of-a-kind eatery. If you loved this place, you’ll also want to visit The Classic Garage in Eau Claire. This restaurant sits inside an old car service station, and it’s full of fun and nostalgic atmosphere. Their chili cheese fries can’t be beat. What are the best delis in Wisconsin? CC Sandwiches, located in Cambridge, is one of the best delis in Wisconsin. If you’re craving a hearty sandwich, this is the place to go. Even though it’s located in a teeny tiny small town, CC Sandwiches is worth the visit. People always rave about their brisket sandwich. This delightful dish is loaded with bacon jam and wedged between a soft pretzel bun. What could be better? Fraboni’s Deli, located in Monona, is another popular place to get a sandwich. This classic Italian eatery whips up some of the most scrumptious lunches you’ve ever had the pleasure of eating. What are the best family-friendly restaurants in Wisconsin? Pizza Doctors, located in La Crosse, is one of the best family-friendly restaurants in Wisconsin. Almost everyone loves pizza, so you can never go wrong here. But that’s not the only amazing thing about this place. They also have delicious salad and dessert buffets! Mama Maria’s, located in Hudson, is another great place to dine with the family. Their kid’s menu is full of tasty classics, and adults can enjoy their fresh seafood dishes.
The OIYS Visitor Center
peanut butter and jelly shop in Wisconsin
April 04, 2020
Elisa Regulski
What are the most unique restaurants in Wisconsin? Georgie Porgie’s, located in Oak Creek and Mount Pleasant, is one of the most unique restaurants in Wisconsin. As soon as you step inside, you’ll feel like you entered another world. Yes, this eatery is treehouse-themed, and it’s just as magical as it sounds. Enjoy delicious burgers and freshly made custard. You’re going to love this one-of-a-kind eatery. If you loved this place, you’ll also want to visit The Classic Garage in Eau Claire. This restaurant sits inside an old car service station, and it’s full of fun and nostalgic atmosphere. Their chili cheese fries can’t be beat. What are the best delis in Wisconsin? CC Sandwiches, located in Cambridge, is one of the best delis in Wisconsin. If you’re craving a hearty sandwich, this is the place to go. Even though it’s located in a teeny tiny small town, CC Sandwiches is worth the visit. People always rave about their brisket sandwich. This delightful dish is loaded with bacon jam and wedged between a soft pretzel bun. What could be better? Fraboni’s Deli, located in Monona, is another popular place to get a sandwich. This classic Italian eatery whips up some of the most scrumptious lunches you’ve ever had the pleasure of eating. What are the best family-friendly restaurants in Wisconsin? Pizza Doctors, located in La Crosse, is one of the best family-friendly restaurants in Wisconsin. Almost everyone loves pizza, so you can never go wrong here. But that’s not the only amazing thing about this place. They also have delicious salad and dessert buffets! Mama Maria’s, located in Hudson, is another great place to dine with the family. Their kid’s menu is full of tasty classics, and adults can enjoy their fresh seafood dishes.
The OIYS Visitor Center
The OIYS Visitor Center
Georgie Porgie’s, located in Oak Creek and Mount Pleasant, is one of the most unique restaurants in Wisconsin. As soon as you step inside, you’ll feel like you entered another world. Yes, this eatery is treehouse-themed, and it’s just as magical as it sounds. Enjoy delicious burgers and freshly made custard. You’re going to love this one-of-a-kind eatery. If you loved this place, you’ll also want to visit The Classic Garage in Eau Claire. This restaurant sits inside an old car service station, and it’s full of fun and nostalgic atmosphere. Their chili cheese fries can’t be beat.
What are the best delis in Wisconsin?
CC Sandwiches, located in Cambridge, is one of the best delis in Wisconsin. If you’re craving a hearty sandwich, this is the place to go. Even though it’s located in a teeny tiny small town, CC Sandwiches is worth the visit. People always rave about their brisket sandwich. This delightful dish is loaded with bacon jam and wedged between a soft pretzel bun. What could be better? Fraboni’s Deli, located in Monona, is another popular place to get a sandwich. This classic Italian eatery whips up some of the most scrumptious lunches you’ve ever had the pleasure of eating.
What are the best family-friendly restaurants in Wisconsin?
Pizza Doctors, located in La Crosse, is one of the best family-friendly restaurants in Wisconsin. Almost everyone loves pizza, so you can never go wrong here. But that’s not the only amazing thing about this place. They also have delicious salad and dessert buffets! Mama Maria’s, located in Hudson, is another great place to dine with the family. Their kid’s menu is full of tasty classics, and adults can enjoy their fresh seafood dishes.
