There are plenty of things that Buffalonians have disagreements over – like which restaurant in Western New York serves up the best wings, for example. However, if there’s one thing that we can all agree on, it’s the fact that we thoroughly enjoy getting the most bang for our buck. If you make your way just east of the city, you’ll discover a mouthwatering restaurant where you even have the chance to eat for free… if you’re up for a hefty challenge. If that sounds like something that’s right up your alley, then see what massive delights await you at the Elma Towne Grille.

Roughly 14 miles east of Buffalo, the Elma Towne Grille is one of the most delicious restaurants in all of Erie County.

Google Maps

A favorite roadside gem among those of us who live here in Western New York, the Elma Towne Grille is one of those restaurants that’s cozy and easily makes you feel right at home.

Peter Armlovich/Google

Your tastebuds will be delighted to discover things like the famous Buffalo Chicken Wing Soup, Pizza Logs, Poutine Fries, and more on the menu.

Derrick Antaya/Google There is also a variety of delicious hot sandwiches, quesadillas, wings, jumbo chicken fingers, Greek souvlaki, all-you-can-eat soups and salads, seafood platters, and homemade favorites like Cheddar Bacon Potato Cakes, crabcakes, mac and cheese, and goulash.

As absolutely mouthwatering as the entirety of the Elma Towne Grille’s menu is, there’s one slice of this restaurant that you’ll absolutely want to take on if you’re brave and hungry enough to do so.

Elma Towne Grille/Facebook

The Elma Towne Grille has its very own Big Elma Burger Challenge that’s been around for nearly 10 years and has been attempted by almost 200 people.

Elma Towne Grille/Facebook

Visitors who take on this challenge will come face-to-face with a burger made up of six five-ounce patties topped with cheese, bacon, onion rings, lettuce, tomato, and pickles served on a toasted Costanza roll.

Elma Towne Grille/Facebook Woah, baby!

There’s also the fact that with the challenge comes 2.5 to 3 pounds of french fries and you have to eat it all in 45 minutes.

Elma Towne Grille/Facebook If you’re able to accomplish this massive and delicious task, you’ll get your meal for free. If you’re unable to eat all of the Big Elma Burger, you’ll have to pay for your meal and put your picture on the Wall of Shame. Seems worth trying, huh?

To find out more about dining at the Elma Towne Grille, click here!

Elma Towne Grille/Facebook Hours: Daily from 11:30 a.m. to 12 a.m.

Ready to take on more of Western New York’s most unique places to eat at? Then be sure to also read about how you can Dine Among Presidents And History At The Founding Fathers Pub In Buffalo!

Google Maps

Peter Armlovich/Google

Derrick Antaya/Google

There is also a variety of delicious hot sandwiches, quesadillas, wings, jumbo chicken fingers, Greek souvlaki, all-you-can-eat soups and salads, seafood platters, and homemade favorites like Cheddar Bacon Potato Cakes, crabcakes, mac and cheese, and goulash.

Elma Towne Grille/Facebook

Woah, baby!

If you’re able to accomplish this massive and delicious task, you’ll get your meal for free. If you’re unable to eat all of the Big Elma Burger, you’ll have to pay for your meal and put your picture on the Wall of Shame. Seems worth trying, huh?

Hours: Daily from 11:30 a.m. to 12 a.m.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.

Address: 6650 Clinton St, Elma, NY 14059, USA